Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore
Which paint brand is best for Montana's extreme climate?
The Verdict for Montana
For most Montana homeowners, Sherwin-Williams Duration offers the best value. It's 10-15% less expensive than Benjamin Moore Aura while providing comparable UV resistance and durability in Montana's extreme climate. However, if you're using dark exterior colors or want one-coat coverage, Benjamin Moore Aura is worth the premium.
🏆 Choose Sherwin-Williams If:
- ✓ Value is important
- ✓ You need easy touch-up paint access
- ✓ Using lighter colors
- ✓ Large project (cost savings add up)
🏆 Choose Benjamin Moore If:
- ✓ Using dark/bold colors
- ✓ Want one-coat coverage
- ✓ Maximum color retention priority
- ✓ Budget allows for premium
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Sherwin-Williams | Benjamin Moore | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premium Exterior Line | Duration Exterior | Aura Exterior | 🤝 Tie |
| Price (per gallon) | $65-85 | $75-95 | ✓ Sherwin-Williams |
| UV Resistance | Excellent | Excellent | 🤝 Tie |
| Color Retention | 7-10 years | 8-10 years | ✓ Benjamin Moore |
| One-Coat Coverage | Good | Excellent | ✓ Benjamin Moore |
| Low-VOC Options | Harmony line | Natura line | 🤝 Tie |
| Warranty | Lifetime limited | Lifetime limited | 🤝 Tie |
| Availability in Bozeman | 2 locations | 1 location | ✓ Sherwin-Williams |
Best Products for Montana
Exterior Paint Recommendations
Best Overall
Best Budget
Best for Dark Colors
Interior Paint Recommendations
Best Overall
Best Zero-VOC
Best for Bathrooms
Montana-Specific Considerations
UV Exposure at 7,500ft
Both brands offer UV-resistant lines suitable for Montana's intense high-altitude sun
Temperature Extremes (-30°F to 95°F)
Both formulated for extreme temperature swings common in Montana
Moisture & Snow
Premium lines from both brands handle Montana moisture well
Professional Preference in Bozeman
Sherwin-Williams more popular with Montana contractors due to availability and support
Cost Analysis for Montana Homes
| Project | Sherwin-Williams | Benjamin Moore | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Average 2,000 sq ft home exterior | $1,200-1,600 | $1,400-1,900 | Benjamin Moore 15-20% more expensive |
| Whole house interior | $800-1,200 | $1,000-1,400 | Benjamin Moore 20-25% more expensive |
| 5-year touch-up costs | $200-300 | $150-250 | Benjamin Moore slightly lower (better color retention) |
Bottom Line: For a typical whole-home project, choosing Sherwin-Williams over Benjamin Moore saves $300-600 on materials. Over 10 years, this difference decreases due to Benjamin Moore's slightly better color retention requiring fewer touch-ups.
Need Help Choosing?
We use both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore paints depending on your specific project needs. Get a free consultation to determine which paint is best for your Montana home.
You can also review our expert answer on best exterior paint for Montana weather before booking.
Call (406) 508-5903